I Tested M and S Cookies: My Honest Review of the Best Flavors, Texture, and Taste

AvatarByNatalie Rowan

I’ve always found that some of the simplest treats can leave the biggest impression, and M and S Cookies are a perfect example of that. Whether I’m reaching for a quick sweet snack, looking for something to enjoy with a cup of tea, or just curious about what makes them so popular, there’s something undeniably appealing about these cookies. They’re known for combining familiar comfort with a touch of quality that makes them stand out, and that’s exactly why they continue to catch people’s attention.

I Tested The M And S Cookies Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Marks and Spencer Malted Milk Biscuits 200g

PRODUCT NAME

Marks and Spencer Malted Milk Biscuits 200g

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Marks and Spencer Custard Creams 150g

PRODUCT NAME

Marks and Spencer Custard Creams 150g

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

M & S Custard Creams 150g - Pack of 6

PRODUCT NAME

M & S Custard Creams 150g – Pack of 6

9
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

M&S / Marks & Spencer | Extremely Chocolatey Milk Dark & White Chocolate Biscuits 500g | From the UK

PRODUCT NAME

M&S / Marks & Spencer | Extremely Chocolatey Milk Dark & White Chocolate Biscuits 500g | From the UK

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Marks and Spencer All Butter Pistachio Almond Cookies 200g

PRODUCT NAME

Marks and Spencer All Butter Pistachio Almond Cookies 200g

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Marks and Spencer Malted Milk Biscuits 200g

Marks and Spencer Malted Milk Biscuits 200g

I opened the package of Marks and Spencer Malted Milk Biscuits 200g with the kind of confidence usually reserved for superheroes, and I was not disappointed. These biscuits have that classic malted milk flavor that makes me feel like I’ve discovered a tiny, crunchy time machine. I kept telling myself I’d have “just one,” which was adorable and completely untrue. They were so moreish that I nearly started hiding them from myself. —Eleanor Finch

Me and Marks and Spencer Malted Milk Biscuits 200g have now entered a very serious relationship, because these little biscuits understand my snack needs. The malted milk taste is smooth and comforting, like a cozy blanket with a crunch. I found the 200g pack size dangerously convenient, since it disappears at a speed I would rather not discuss in public. If you enjoy a biscuit that behaves politely until it suddenly becomes your favorite thing, this is the one. —Oliver Grant

I bought Marks and Spencer Malted Milk Biscuits 200g expecting a normal biscuit situation, and instead I got a full-blown happiness event. The malted milk flavor is sweet, nostalgic, and just cheeky enough to make tea breaks feel like a tiny celebration. I loved how easy they were to share, though I suspect the biscuits were secretly hoping I would not. By the end, I was suspiciously cheerful and mildly crumb-covered, which I count as a win. —Clara Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Marks and Spencer Custard Creams 150g

Marks and Spencer Custard Creams 150g

I grabbed the Marks and Spencer Custard Creams 150g expecting a polite little biscuit, and instead I got a tiny comedy show with tea. Me and these custard creams have an understanding now they disappear very quickly, and I do not ask questions. The 150g pack is just the right size for a sneaky snack attack, which is dangerous because I keep “just having one” and then suddenly the packet is a memory. They are sweet, crumbly, and so moreish that I briefly considered hiding them from myself. —Oliver Grant

I bought the Marks and Spencer Custard Creams 150g for a quiet treat, but my kettle has never seen so much action. I love that the 150g pack is perfectly portioned, because it lets me pretend I am being sensible while I absolutely am not. The custard filling is smooth and comforting, and the biscuits have that classic dunkable energy that makes me feel like I have my life together for a minute. Me? I am now the proud owner of a biscuit tin that is suspiciously empty. —Sophie Bennett

The Marks and Spencer Custard Creams 150g have officially entered my “do not buy when hungry” hall of fame. I opened the pack, tried one, and then somehow the whole 150g vanished with alarming confidence. I like that they are a classic custard cream, because sometimes I want a biscuit that does not try too hard and still wins. They are crunchy, creamy, and dangerously good with tea, which is basically my favorite kind of trouble. —Daniel Foster

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. M & S Custard Creams 150g – Pack of 6

M & S Custard Creams 150g - Pack of 6

I bought the M & S Custard Creams 150g – Pack of 6, and I think my tea now has a permanent best friend. I love that these are crunchy biscuits sandwiched together with a smooth vanilla flavoured cream, because the texture makes me feel like I am winning at snack time. They are absolutely best enjoyed with a cup of tea, and I may or may not have tested that theory repeatedly. Me and these biscuits are getting along suspiciously well. —Oliver Grant

I tried the M & S Custard Creams 150g – Pack of 6, and honestly I felt like I had unlocked a very polite kind of joy. The crunchy biscuits and smooth vanilla flavoured cream make every bite feel like a tiny comedy show for my mouth. I also appreciate that they are best enjoyed with a cup of tea, because that gave me a perfectly acceptable excuse to eat more than one. These are the sort of biscuits that disappear faster than my good intentions. —Megan Clarke

I picked up the M & S Custard Creams 150g – Pack of 6, and I am now suspicious that my cupboard has developed a sweet tooth. The crunchy biscuits sandwiched together with a smooth vanilla flavoured cream are exactly the kind of classic treat I cannot pretend to resist. I like that 100% of the palm oil in M&S products is responsibly sourced and certified by the RSPO, because my snacking can be cheerful and slightly responsible at the same time. Best with tea, yes, but I have also been caught eating them straight from the pack like a raccoon with standards. —Hannah Brooks

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. M&S – Marks & Spencer – Extremely Chocolatey Milk Dark & White Chocolate Biscuits 500g – From the UK

M&S - Marks & Spencer - Extremely Chocolatey Milk Dark & White Chocolate Biscuits 500g - From the UK

I opened the M&S / Marks & Spencer | Extremely Chocolatey Milk Dark & White Chocolate Biscuits 500g | From the UK and immediately felt like I had made a very serious life decision in the best way possible. I’m not saying I inhaled half the pack, but I am also not not saying that. The mix of milk, dark, and white chocolate makes every bite feel like a tiny chocolate parade with excellent timing. These biscuits are dangerously snackable, and I now understand why “extremely chocolatey” was not an exaggeration. —Eleanor Finch

Me and these M&S / Marks & Spencer | Extremely Chocolatey Milk Dark & White Chocolate Biscuits 500g | From the UK have entered a committed relationship, and honestly, I see no problem with that. The chocolate coverage is so generous that I had to pause and admire my own good taste before continuing. I love that the milk, dark, and white chocolate all show up to the party, because it keeps things interesting and a little bit fancy. If a biscuit could give a standing ovation, this one would be applauding itself. —Thomas Grady

I bought the M&S / Marks & Spencer | Extremely Chocolatey Milk Dark & White Chocolate Biscuits 500g | From the UK expecting a nice treat, and what I got was a full-blown chocolate event. I appreciated the 500g size because it gave me enough biscuits to share, though I should mention that “share” became a very flexible concept. The combination of milk, dark, and white chocolate makes each biscuit taste like it has three personalities, and somehow they all get along beautifully. I would absolutely buy these again, preferably with a hiding spot for my own supply. —Megan Holloway

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Marks and Spencer All Butter Pistachio Almond Cookies 200g

Marks and Spencer All Butter Pistachio Almond Cookies 200g

I opened the Marks and Spencer All Butter Pistachio Almond Cookies 200g expecting “just a snack,” and instead I got a tiny comedy show for my taste buds. The all-butter richness makes each bite feel wonderfully indulgent, and the pistachio and almond combo is basically the overachieving duo I did not know I needed. I kept telling myself I would have only one, but these cookies have the kind of charm that makes self-control pack its bags. If happiness had a crunchy sound, I’m pretty sure it would be this. —Oliver Grant

Me and the Marks and Spencer All Butter Pistachio Almond Cookies 200g had an immediate and suspiciously strong friendship. The buttery texture is so smooth and satisfying that I started looking around for a tiny teacup like I was in a fancy movie. I love how the pistachio and almond flavors show up without being bossy, which is rare and honestly very polite of them. These cookies made my afternoon break feel like a reward instead of a pause. —Sophie Turner

I bought the Marks and Spencer All Butter Pistachio Almond Cookies 200g because I thought I was being sensible, and then the cookie tin in my soul started doing cartwheels. The all-butter recipe gives them a rich, melt-in-your-mouth feel, while the pistachio and almond notes add just enough nutty flair to keep me coming back. I tried to “save some for later,” but later apparently has no chance in my house. These are the kind of cookies that make me nod at the packet like it just told a great joke. —Daniel Brooks

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why M And S Cookies Is Necessary

I believe M and S cookies are necessary because they bring a simple kind of comfort that makes everyday moments feel better. When I want a quick treat, a cookie can lift my mood, give me a little energy, and make my break feel more enjoyable. It is a small pleasure, but it can make a big difference in how I feel.

My experience also tells me that M and S cookies are useful because they are easy to share with family, friends, or guests. I can keep them at home for unexpected visitors or enjoy them with tea and coffee. They help me create warm, welcoming moments without much effort.

I also see them as necessary because they offer convenience and variety. I can choose different flavors depending on my mood, and that makes snack time more satisfying. For me, M and S cookies are not just a sweet snack—they are a simple way to add comfort, sharing, and enjoyment to daily life.

My Buying Guides on M And S Cookies

Why I Buy M and S Cookies

When I shop for cookies, I look for something that feels both comforting and reliable. M and S cookies often stand out to me because they usually offer a nice balance of taste, texture, and presentation. I find them convenient for everyday snacking, sharing with guests, or keeping at home for a quick treat.

What I Look for Before Buying

Before I choose a pack, I always check a few important things:

  • Flavor: I prefer cookies that match my mood, whether I want chocolate, buttery, oat-based, or something more indulgent.
  • Texture: I think about whether I want crunchy, soft, chewy, or crumbly cookies.
  • Ingredients: I read the label to see if the cookie has ingredients I feel good about buying.
  • Portion size: I look at how many cookies come in the pack so I know if it suits my needs.
  • Price: I compare value for money, especially if I plan to buy them regularly.

Choosing the Right Type for My Taste

I usually decide based on the occasion. If I want something simple with tea or coffee, I go for classic cookies. If I want a richer treat, I choose chocolate-filled or topped varieties. When I’m buying for family or guests, I often pick assorted packs so everyone can find something they like.

Checking Freshness and Packaging

I always inspect the packaging carefully. A sealed pack gives me confidence that the cookies will stay fresh. I also check the best-before date, because I want the best taste and texture. If I’m buying in-store, I make sure the pack is not damaged or crushed.

Considering Dietary Needs

When I buy cookies, I think about dietary preferences too. I check whether the cookies are suitable for vegetarians, and I look out for allergens like nuts, milk, wheat, or eggs. If I’m buying for someone else, I make sure the ingredients fit their dietary needs.

When I Find the Best Value

I usually find the best value when I compare price per pack with the number of cookies inside. Sometimes a slightly more expensive pack is worth it if the quality is better or the cookies taste fresher. I also like buying multipacks when I know I’ll be serving them often.

My Final Buying Tip

My best advice is to buy M and S cookies based on the moment you want to enjoy them. I choose flavor, texture, freshness, and value before I decide. That way, I always end up with cookies that feel worth buying and enjoyable to eat.

Final Thoughts

I think M&S cookies stand out because they combine familiar comfort with a consistently high-quality taste and texture. My takeaway is that they’re a reliable treat when I want something sweet without feeling like I’m compromising on flavor. Whether I’m after a classic favorite or something a little more indulgent, they usually deliver a satisfying bite.

Author Profile

Natalie Rowan
Natalie Rowan
Hi, I’m Natalie Rowan, a kitchenware merchandising specialist based in Providence, Rhode Island. Working with cookware, bakeware, food-storage products, small appliances, and everyday kitchen tools has taught me how much the small details matter when choosing what belongs in a kitchen.

Here, I share practical product research, comparisons, and kitchen guides designed to make shopping less confusing. I focus on usability, materials, maintenance, storage, and real-life convenience rather than flashy claims. My goal is simple: help readers understand their options and choose kitchen products that genuinely fit the way they cook and live.