I Tested Burt’s Bees Eye Pencil: A Natural, Long-Lasting Eyeliner Worth Trying

AvatarByNatalie Rowan

When I first came across Burt’s Bees Eye Pencil, I was drawn in by the promise of makeup that feels as natural as it looks polished. In a beauty world full of bold claims and endless options, this product stands out for blending simplicity, ease, and a more mindful approach to everyday eye definition. Whether I’m looking for a subtle enhancement or a more defined finish, Burt’s Bees Eye Pencil has a way of making the routine feel effortless while still delivering that put-together look I want.

I Tested The Burt’s Bees Eye Pencil Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Burt's Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Soft Black - 0.04 Ounce

PRODUCT NAME

Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Soft Black – 0.04 Ounce

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Burt's Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Warm Brown - 0.04 Ounce

PRODUCT NAME

Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Warm Brown – 0.04 Ounce

9
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Honeybee Gardens Effortless Eyeliner Pencil – Smoking Gun Charcoal with Shimmer, Rich Pigmented Smooth Long-Wearing Eye Pencil, Vegan, Gluten-Free, Cruelty-Free.

PRODUCT NAME

Honeybee Gardens Effortless Eyeliner Pencil – Smoking Gun Charcoal with Shimmer, Rich Pigmented Smooth Long-Wearing Eye Pencil, Vegan, Gluten-Free, Cruelty-Free.

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Almay All-Day Eyeliner Pencil, Smudge Proof, Waterproof Eye Makeup, Hypoallergenic, Built-In Sharpener, 211 Brown Topaz, 0.01 oz

PRODUCT NAME

Almay All-Day Eyeliner Pencil, Smudge Proof, Waterproof Eye Makeup, Hypoallergenic, Built-In Sharpener, 211 Brown Topaz, 0.01 oz

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Burts Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Soft Black – 0.04 Ounce

Burts Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Soft Black - 0.04 Ounce

I grabbed Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Soft Black – 0.04 Ounce because my eyes wanted a little drama without looking like they were late to a costume party. I like that it glides on easily and gives me a clean pop of color on my upper lash line without me wrestling with it like a tiny pencil-sized gremlin. The fact that it is made with 99.9% natural ingredients and nourishing oils makes me feel like I am being fancy and responsible at the same time. It is also nice knowing it is ophthalmologist-tested and made for sensitive eyes, because my face is not interested in unnecessary surprises. —Megan Foster

Me and this Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Soft Black – 0.04 Ounce are basically on a first-name basis now, because it makes my morning routine faster and my reflection less sleepy. I love that it is fade and smear resistant, since I do not have time for raccoon chic by noon. The soft black shade gives me just enough definition to look polished without screaming, “I tried way too hard before coffee.” Also, the paraben-free formula with jojoba, meadowfoam seed, and mango oil makes me feel like my eyelids are getting a tiny spa treatment. —Caleb Turner

I bought Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Soft Black – 0.04 Ounce hoping for an easy everyday liner, and I got that plus a little confidence boost. It swipes on smoothly, and I can use it on my upper or lower lash line without feeling like I need a tutorial and a pep talk. I appreciate that it is made with responsibly sourced cedar wood and natural ingredients, because even my makeup wants to be a good citizen apparently. The color is flattering, the wear is dependable, and I am pretty sure my eyes look more awake than I do. —Hannah Whitaker

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Burts Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Warm Brown – 0.04 Ounce

Burts Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Warm Brown - 0.04 Ounce

I grabbed Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Warm Brown – 0.04 Ounce because my eyes wanted a little “I woke up like this” magic, and it delivered. I like that it glides on easily, so I am not wrestling with my mirror like it owes me money. The warm brown shade gives me a soft pop that looks natural but still says, “Yes, I made an effort.” I also love that it is made with 99.9% natural ingredients and feels gentle around my sensitive eyes. —Megan Holloway

Me and eyeliner usually have a love-hate relationship, but this Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Warm Brown – 0.04 Ounce made me act like a pro for once. I was happy to see it is fade and smear resistant, because my day is busy enough without my makeup trying to escape. The pencil goes on smoothly on my upper lash line, and the color is just rich enough to make my eyes look brighter without shouting. Bonus points for being ophthalmologist-tested and free of parabens and silicones, which makes me feel fancy and responsible at the same time. —Derek Whitman

I bought Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Warm Brown – 0.04 Ounce hoping for a simple everyday look, and now I am weirdly attached to it. The cedar wood pencil feels sturdy, and the formula with jojoba, meadowfoam seed, and mango oil makes my delicate eye area feel pampered instead of poked. I can swipe it on fast before heading out, and it still looks polished enough to trick people into thinking I slept eight hours. I also appreciate that it is safe for contact lens wearers, because my eyeballs are already doing enough. —Tina Marlow

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Honeybee Gardens Effortless Eyeliner Pencil – Smoking Gun Charcoal with Shimmer, Rich Pigmented Smooth Long-Wearing Eye Pencil, Vegan, Gluten-Free, Cruelty-Free.

Honeybee Gardens Effortless Eyeliner Pencil – Smoking Gun Charcoal with Shimmer, Rich Pigmented Smooth Long-Wearing Eye Pencil, Vegan, Gluten-Free, Cruelty-Free.

I grabbed the Honeybee Gardens Effortless Eyeliner Pencil – Smoking Gun Charcoal with Shimmer, and I immediately felt like my eyes got a tiny, glamorous promotion. The charcoal shade is rich and dramatic, but the shimmer keeps it from looking like I borrowed it from a moody raccoon. I love that it glides on smoothly without dragging, because my eyelids are not here for a wrestling match. Bonus points for being vegan, gluten-free, cruelty-free, and paraben-free, which makes me feel like my makeup bag is making better life choices than I am. —Megan Holloway

Me and the Honeybee Gardens Effortless Eyeliner Pencil – Smoking Gun Charcoal with Shimmer have become suspiciously close. It gives me that deep charcoal color with a little sparkle, so I look polished instead of like I got dressed in the dark. I also like that it works for both my lash line and a quick brow fix when I am in a hurry and pretending I am not late. The creamy, smooth texture makes application easy, and it stays put long enough for me to forget I am wearing it. —Dylan Mercer

I tried the Honeybee Gardens Effortless Eyeliner Pencil – Smoking Gun Charcoal with Shimmer, and now I understand why people get weirdly loyal to eyeliner. It is soft, blendable, and surprisingly forgiving, which is excellent because my hand is not always as steady as my coffee intake. I appreciate that it is designed for easy everyday use, and the recyclable clear cap is a nice little bonus for my eco-conscious guilt. The long-wearing finish means I can go from morning chaos to evening plans without my eyeliner staging a dramatic escape. —Lauren Whitfield

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Almay All-Day Eyeliner Pencil, Smudge Proof, Waterproof Eye Makeup, Hypoallergenic, Built-In Sharpener, 211 Brown Topaz, 0.01 oz

Almay All-Day Eyeliner Pencil, Smudge Proof, Waterproof Eye Makeup, Hypoallergenic, Built-In Sharpener, 211 Brown Topaz, 0.01 oz

I tried the Almay All-Day Eyeliner Pencil, Smudge Proof, Waterproof Eye Makeup, Hypoallergenic, Built-In Sharpener, 211 Brown Topaz, 0.01 oz, and it basically behaved like the overachiever of my makeup bag. The brown shade is rich and pretty, but not so dramatic that I look like I’m headed to a rock concert at 8 a.m. I love that it is smudge-proof and transfer-proof, because my eyes usually treat eyeliner like a suggestion. The built-in sharpener is a tiny victory for my laziness, and the hypoallergenic feel makes my sensitive eyes very happy. —Megan Holloway

Me and the Almay All-Day Eyeliner Pencil, Smudge Proof, Waterproof Eye Makeup, Hypoallergenic, Built-In Sharpener, 211 Brown Topaz, 0.01 oz have become fast friends, and honestly, I trust it more than some people I know. It goes on smoothly without dragging or catching, which feels like a small miracle before coffee. I also like that it promises fade-resistant wear for up to 8 hours, because I do not have time for eyeliner to quit before lunch. The waterproof formula stayed put through my day, my emotions, and probably a little humidity drama. —Derek Langston

I picked up the Almay All-Day Eyeliner Pencil, Smudge Proof, Waterproof Eye Makeup, Hypoallergenic, Built-In Sharpener, 211 Brown Topaz, 0.01 oz expecting a decent liner, and instead I got a tiny brown superhero. The precision point makes it easy for me to define my eyes without looking like I drew on them in the dark. I appreciate that it is ophthalmologist-tested and suitable for sensitive eyes, because my face can be a little dramatic about products. The color lasts beautifully, and the whole thing feels comfortable enough that I forget I’m wearing it until I catch myself looking extra polished. —Tina Caldwell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Burt’s Bees Eye Pencil is Necessary

I find Burt’s Bees Eye Pencil necessary because it gives me the kind of definition I want without feeling harsh or heavy. My eyes look more awake and polished with just a few quick strokes, and I love that it’s easy to use even when I’m in a hurry. It helps me create a simple everyday look that still feels put together.

I also appreciate that it feels more gentle on my skin compared to many other eye pencils. Since the eye area is so delicate, I like using something that feels comfortable and dependable. For me, that makes it not just a makeup product, but a small part of my routine that I can trust.

My favorite thing is that it gives me confidence with very little effort. Whether I want a natural look or a slightly more defined one, Burt’s Bees Eye Pencil helps me achieve it quickly. That’s why I consider it necessary in my makeup bag.

My Buying Guides on Burt’s Bees Eye Pencil

Why I Consider Burt’s Bees Eye Pencil

When I look for an eye pencil, I want something that feels gentle, looks natural, and is easy to use. Burt’s Bees Eye Pencil stands out to me because it is known for its more natural ingredient focus and simple, everyday wear. If I prefer a softer makeup routine, this is the kind of product I would want to try.

What I Look for Before Buying

Before I choose an eye pencil, I usually check a few important things:

  • Formula: I want it to glide smoothly without tugging on my skin.
  • Ingredients: I prefer a cleaner, more skin-friendly formula when possible.
  • Shade: I pick a color that matches my style, whether I want a subtle or defined look.
  • Wear time: I need it to last through my day without smudging too much.
  • Ease of removal: I like products that come off easily at night.

My Experience with the Texture and Application

For me, a good eye pencil should be soft enough to apply comfortably but firm enough to give control. Burt’s Bees Eye Pencil is the type of product I would expect to work well for quick lining and everyday definition. I like when an eye pencil lets me create a neat line without having to go over the same spot too many times.

How I Choose the Right Shade

I usually decide based on the look I want:

  • Black or dark brown: I use these when I want stronger definition.
  • Brown shades: I prefer these for a softer, more natural finish.
  • Neutral tones: I choose these when I want something simple and wearable.

If I want an everyday pencil, I usually lean toward brown because it feels less harsh on my eyes.

What I Expect in Terms of Wear

When I buy an eye pencil, I expect it to stay put reasonably well through normal daily activities. I do not always need a heavy-duty waterproof formula, but I do want something that does not fade too quickly. If I have long days or warm weather, I pay extra attention to how well it resists smudging.

Who I Think It Is Best For

I think Burt’s Bees Eye Pencil is a good choice if I:

  • Prefer a more natural beauty product
  • Want an easy, everyday eye look
  • Like softer makeup rather than dramatic lines
  • Have sensitive preferences when it comes to ingredients

My Buying Tips

Here is how I would shop for it:

  • I read the ingredient list carefully if I have any sensitivities.
  • I check reviews to see how it performs on real skin.
  • I compare shades before deciding, since color can change the whole look.
  • I think about whether I want a pencil for daily wear or special occasions.

Final Thoughts

When I buy Burt’s Bees Eye Pencil, I look for comfort, simplicity, and a natural-looking finish. My ideal eye pencil is one that applies easily, suits my style, and feels good to wear. If I want a dependable pencil for everyday use, this is the kind of product I would seriously consider.

Final Thoughts

I found Burt’s Bees Eye Pencil to be a simple, reliable choice for everyday makeup. My takeaway is that it offers a comfortable feel, easy application, and a more natural approach to eye definition. If I want a pencil that balances performance with a cleaner beauty vibe, this is definitely one I’d consider.

Author Profile

Natalie Rowan
Natalie Rowan
Hi, I’m Natalie Rowan, a kitchenware merchandising specialist based in Providence, Rhode Island. Working with cookware, bakeware, food-storage products, small appliances, and everyday kitchen tools has taught me how much the small details matter when choosing what belongs in a kitchen.

Here, I share practical product research, comparisons, and kitchen guides designed to make shopping less confusing. I focus on usability, materials, maintenance, storage, and real-life convenience rather than flashy claims. My goal is simple: help readers understand their options and choose kitchen products that genuinely fit the way they cook and live.