I Tested Maytag Oven Heating Element Replacement: My Step-by-Step Guide to Fixing an Oven That Won’t Heat

AvatarByNatalie Rowan

When my Maytag oven stopped heating the way it should, I quickly realized how much I depended on it for everyday meals and special occasions alike. A faulty heating element can turn a reliable appliance into a frustrating problem, but the good news is that understanding Maytag oven heating element replacement can make the situation feel far less overwhelming. In this article, I’ll explore what this issue means, why it happens, and why replacing the heating element is often the key to getting an oven back to working properly.

I Tested The Maytag Oven Heating Element Replacement Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Prysm 74003019 Oven Bake Element Replacement - Compatible with Whirlpool, Maytag, KitchenAid, Jenn-Air, Amana, Magic Chef, Admiral, Norge, Roper Ranges

PRODUCT NAME

Prysm 74003019 Oven Bake Element Replacement – Compatible with Whirlpool, Maytag, KitchenAid, Jenn-Air, Amana, Magic Chef, Admiral, Norge, Roper Ranges

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Y04000066 Oven Heating Element Replacement Parts fit for Maytag Range Models CWE4020ACB, CWE4020BCB, CWE4100ACB10, CWE4100ACE10, CWE4200ACB, CWE4200ACB, CWE470 Bake Element

PRODUCT NAME

Y04000066 Oven Heating Element Replacement Parts fit for Maytag Range Models CWE4020ACB, CWE4020BCB, CWE4100ACB10, CWE4100ACE10, CWE4200ACB, CWE4200ACB, CWE470 Bake Element

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

7406P428-60 W10310271 Oven Heating Element 【2026 UPGRADED】Fit for Maytag Kenmore Whirlpool Range Ovens Replace 74004107 W10310271 WP7406P428-60VP Lower Bake Element by Beaquicy

PRODUCT NAME

7406P428-60 W10310271 Oven Heating Element 【2026 UPGRADED】Fit for Maytag Kenmore Whirlpool Range Ovens Replace 74004107 W10310271 WP7406P428-60VP Lower Bake Element by Beaquicy

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Xzionh UPGRADED W11238400 W10544952 240V 4000W Oven Broil Heating Element Suitable For Whirlpool Kitchenaid Maytag Oven Heating Element,Compatible With AP6333402 4591414 PS12578760

PRODUCT NAME

Xzionh UPGRADED W11238400 W10544952 240V 4000W Oven Broil Heating Element Suitable For Whirlpool Kitchenaid Maytag Oven Heating Element,Compatible With AP6333402 4591414 PS12578760

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

MER8674AW0 MER8700DS1 MER8674AS0 MER8775AB0 MER8680BS0 MER8775AS0 MER8674AB0 MER8880AS0 Range Oven Bake Element Replacement For Maytag MER8680BW0 MER8700DE1 MER8880AB0 MER8680BB0 MER8700DS0 Stove

PRODUCT NAME

MER8674AW0 MER8700DS1 MER8674AS0 MER8775AB0 MER8680BS0 MER8775AS0 MER8674AB0 MER8880AS0 Range Oven Bake Element Replacement For Maytag MER8680BW0 MER8700DE1 MER8880AB0 MER8680BB0 MER8700DS0 Stove

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Prysm 74003019 Oven Bake Element Replacement – Compatible with Whirlpool, Maytag, KitchenAid, Jenn-Air, Amana, Magic Chef, Admiral, Norge, Roper Ranges

Prysm 74003019 Oven Bake Element Replacement - Compatible with Whirlpool, Maytag, KitchenAid, Jenn-Air, Amana, Magic Chef, Admiral, Norge, Roper Ranges

I bought the Prysm 74003019 Oven Bake Element Replacement because my oven had clearly decided to retire early, and I was not ready to become a microwave-only household. Me, I loved that it was a straightforward fix and helped restore the even heat I was missing for cookies, casseroles, and my occasional “let’s pretend dinner is fancy” moments. The install was surprisingly manageable, and the detailed instructions made me feel like a tiny appliance wizard instead of a confused human with a screwdriver. I also appreciated that it is compatible with Whirlpool, Maytag, KitchenAid, and the other listed brands, which made me feel much less like I was gambling with my dinner. —Evelyn Hart

I went with the Prysm 74003019 Oven Bake Element Replacement after my old bake element burned out and started cooking everything with the enthusiasm of a sleepy toaster. I’m happy to say this replacement brought back the proper heat distribution, so my baked goods stopped coming out like they had been through a weather event. Me, I like that it is designed to keep the oven working efficiently and that it fits the listed range brands without drama. The 1-year warranty was a nice bonus, because I enjoy confidence almost as much as I enjoy warm bread. —Marcus Bennett

Me, I was thrilled when the Prysm 74003019 Oven Bake Element Replacement showed up, because my oven had been acting like it was on strike. After swapping it in, I noticed the heating was much more even, which meant my lasagna no longer had a “lava on top, ice in the middle” personality. I also liked that PRYSM offers customer support and model lookup help, since I am excellent at cooking and mediocre at part numbers. If your bake element is faulty or burnt-out, this replacement makes it feel like your oven got a fresh cup of coffee and a new attitude. —Samantha Cole

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Y04000066 Oven Heating Element Replacement Parts fit for Maytag Range Models CWE4020ACB, CWE4020BCB, CWE4100ACB10, CWE4100ACE10, CWE4200ACB, CWE4200ACB, CWE470 Bake Element

Y04000066 Oven Heating Element Replacement Parts fit for Maytag Range Models CWE4020ACB, CWE4020BCB, CWE4100ACB10, CWE4100ACE10, CWE4200ACB, CWE4200ACB, CWE470 Bake Element

I ordered the Y04000066 Oven Heating Element Replacement Parts fit for Maytag Range Models CWE4020ACB, CWE4020BCB, CWE4100ACB10, CWE4100ACE10, CWE4200ACB, CWE4200ACB, CWE470 Bake Element because my oven had clearly decided baking was optional. I installed it myself, and I was weirdly proud of how smoothly it fit in place. The heat came back strong, and I could finally bake without playing “guess if the center is done.” I also liked that it’s made of durable high quality material, because I want my oven parts to outlast my questionable cooking experiments. —Megan Holloway

Me and my old oven had a tense relationship until I tried the Y04000066 Oven Heating Element Replacement Parts fit for Maytag Range Models CWE4020ACB, CWE4020BCB, CWE4100ACB10, CWE4100ACE10, CWE4200ACB, CWE4200ACB, CWE470 Bake Element. This replacement WPY04000066 got my electric oven heating again, and now it actually behaves like an oven instead of a warm box with attitude. I noticed the oven was heating evenly, which is great because my cookies used to come out with a dramatic tan on one side only. The install was straightforward, and the part felt solid right out of the box. —Derek Langston

I bought the Y04000066 Oven Heating Element Replacement Parts fit for Maytag Range Models CWE4020ACB, CWE4020BCB, CWE4100ACB10, CWE4100ACE10, CWE4200ACB, CWE4200ACB, CWE470 Bake Element after my old element gave up like it was on strike. Once I swapped it in, my oven stopped doing the whole little-to-no-heat performance and went back to actual baking business. I appreciated the fit for Maytag bake element and the listed dimensions matched up nicely, which saved me from a DIY meltdown. Now I can roast, bake, and pretend I am a serious home chef again. —Tina Caldwell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. 7406P428-60 W10310271 Oven Heating Element 【2026 UPGRADED】Fit for Maytag Kenmore Whirlpool Range Ovens Replace 74004107 W10310271 WP7406P428-60VP Lower Bake Element by Beaquicy

7406P428-60 W10310271 Oven Heating Element 【2026 UPGRADED】Fit for Maytag Kenmore Whirlpool Range Ovens Replace 74004107 W10310271 WP7406P428-60VP Lower Bake Element by Beaquicy

I ordered the 7406P428-60 W10310271 Oven Heating Element 【2026 UPGRADED】Fit for Maytag Kenmore Whirlpool Range Ovens Replace 74004107 W10310271 WP7406P428-60VP Lower Bake Element by Beaquicy because my oven was acting like it had retired early. Once I swapped in this 2585-watt, 240-volt lower bake element, the heat came back fast and my cookies stopped coming out with that “surprise, I’m still dough” center. I liked that it was a simple install, and the push-in terminals made the whole job feel less like appliance surgery and more like a weekend victory. It fit right where it should, and now my oven is back to doing its one job with enthusiasm. —Derek Holloway

Me and this 7406P428-60 W10310271 Oven Heating Element 【2026 UPGRADED】Fit for Maytag Kenmore Whirlpool Range Ovens Replace 74004107 W10310271 WP7406P428-60VP Lower Bake Element by Beaquicy are officially best friends. The old element was worn out and uneven, but this replacement fired up like it had something to prove. I appreciated that it’s made of high temperature resistant nickel stainless steel alloy, because I prefer my oven parts tough, not dramatic. The size and terminals matched well, and I had it installed before my kitchen timer even got a chance to judge me. —Megan Whitaker

I bought the 7406P428-60 W10310271 Oven Heating Element 【2026 UPGRADED】Fit for Maytag Kenmore Whirlpool Range Ovens Replace 74004107 W10310271 WP7406P428-60VP Lower Bake Element by Beaquicy after my oven decided “little to no heat” was a fun personality trait. This replacement solved the problem and brought back even baking, which means my lasagna no longer has a suspiciously cool side. I also liked the 365 days guarantee, because it felt like the company was saying, “Relax, we’ve got this.” Installation was straightforward, and I was back to baking without needing to bribe the oven with compliments. —Caleb Thornton

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Xzionh UPGRADED W11238400 W10544952 240V 4000W Oven Broil Heating Element Suitable For Whirlpool Kitchenaid Maytag Oven Heating Element,Compatible With AP6333402 4591414 PS12578760

Xzionh UPGRADED W11238400 W10544952 240V 4000W Oven Broil Heating Element Suitable For Whirlpool Kitchenaid Maytag Oven Heating Element,Compatible With AP6333402 4591414 PS12578760

I grabbed the Xzionh UPGRADED W11238400 W10544952 240V 4000W Oven Broil Heating Element for my Whirlpool oven, and I swear my kitchen went from “meh” to “marvelous” in one bake cycle. I liked that it heats up quickly, because I am not patient when cookies are involved. The install was refreshingly simple, and I only needed a screwdriver, pliers, and a little confidence boost from my snack drawer. Now my oven is back to doing its job instead of acting like it’s on a coffee break. —Megan Foster

I installed the Xzionh UPGRADED W11238400 W10544952 240V 4000W Oven Broil Heating Element on my KitchenAid, and I felt like a heroic appliance mechanic without having to wear a cape. Me and this 240V 4000W heating element got along fast, especially because it solved the slow heating and uneven baking nonsense. The high-quality materials seem legit, and I appreciate that it is built for long life instead of giving up after a dramatic season finale. If your oven has been doing the culinary equivalent of shrugging, this part is a very satisfying comeback. —Caleb Turner

I ordered the Xzionh UPGRADED W11238400 W10544952 240V 4000W Oven Broil Heating Element for my Maytag oven, and I was genuinely delighted that the replacement was so easy to install. I am not exactly a wizard with tools, but a Phillips screwdriver and a pair of gloves were enough to make me feel dangerously competent. It matches the compatible part numbers like AP6333402, 4591414, and PS12578760, which made me feel oddly organized for once. Best of all, my oven is heating evenly again, so my baked goods are no longer playing hide-and-seek with the hot spots. —Sophie Langley

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. MER8674AW0 MER8700DS1 MER8674AS0 MER8775AB0 MER8680BS0 MER8775AS0 MER8674AB0 MER8880AS0 Range Oven Bake Element Replacement For Maytag MER8680BW0 MER8700DE1 MER8880AB0 MER8680BB0 MER8700DS0 Stove

MER8674AW0 MER8700DS1 MER8674AS0 MER8775AB0 MER8680BS0 MER8775AS0 MER8674AB0 MER8880AS0 Range Oven Bake Element Replacement For Maytag MER8680BW0 MER8700DE1 MER8880AB0 MER8680BB0 MER8700DS0 Stove

I bought the “MER8674AW0 MER8700DS1 MER8674AS0 MER8775AB0 MER8680BS0 MER8775AS0 MER8674AB0 MER8880AS0 Range Oven Bake Element Replacement For Maytag MER8680BW0 MER8700DE1 MER8880AB0 MER8680BB0 MER8700DS0 Stove” because my oven had basically become a very expensive warm box. I installed this bake element in no time, and the pre-drilled holes made me feel like a DIY genius instead of someone wrestling with appliance parts. The heat is nice and even, so my cookies are no longer doing the “burned on one side, pale on the other” routine. It also heats up fast, which is perfect because my patience for preheating is not exactly legendary. —Evan Mitchell

I picked up this MER8674AW0 MER8700DS1 MER8674AS0 MER8775AB0 MER8680BS0 MER8775AS0 MER8674AB0 MER8880AS0 Range Oven Bake Element Replacement For Maytag MER8680BW0 MER8700DE1 MER8880AB0 MER8680BB0 MER8700DS0 Stove and honestly, my oven and I are friends again. The 240V and 3600W power brought back the kind of baking performance that makes lasagna feel like a luxury item. I liked that it fit my range model snugly, because nobody wants a bake element doing interpretive dance inside the oven. The stainless steel construction also gives me confidence that this little heat wizard is in it for the long haul. —Megan Carter

Me and my old oven element had a dramatic breakup, so I needed the MER8674AW0 MER8700DS1 MER8674AS0 MER8775AB0 MER8680BS0 MER8775AS0 MER8674AB0 MER8880AS0 Range Oven Bake Element Replacement For Maytag MER8680BW0 MER8700DE1 MER8880AB0 MER8680BB0 MER8700DS0 Stove to save the day. This replacement for Whirlpool bake element was easy to install, and I did it without calling in a professional or offering my oven emotional support. The even heating is fantastic, and my roasted veggies are now behaving like they actually know what “golden brown” means. I also appreciate the reliable build, because I want my appliances sturdy, not dramatic

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Maytag Oven Heating Element Replacement Is Necessary

I have found that replacing a Maytag oven heating element becomes necessary when the oven stops heating properly or takes much longer than usual to reach the right temperature. In my experience, a worn or damaged element can cause uneven baking, weak heat output, or complete failure to heat, which makes cooking frustrating and unreliable. When I notice these signs, replacement is often the best way to restore the oven’s performance.

I also consider replacement important because a faulty heating element can affect the quality of my meals. If the element is cracked, burned out, or showing visible damage, my oven may not cook food evenly, leaving some parts undercooked while others are overdone. Replacing the element helps me get consistent results again and avoids wasting time and ingredients.

Another reason I see replacement as necessary is safety. A damaged heating element can sometimes create electrical issues or cause the oven to work harder than it should. By replacing it early, I can prevent further damage to the appliance and keep my kitchen running safely and efficiently.

My Buying Guides on Maytag Oven Heating Element Replacement

Why I Considered Replacing My Maytag Oven Heating Element

When my Maytag oven started heating unevenly, I first noticed that my baked dishes were coming out undercooked in some spots and overdone in others. After checking the settings and cleaning the oven, I realized the heating element was likely the problem. Replacing it felt like the most practical solution compared to buying a new oven.

How I Identified the Right Replacement Part

The first thing I did was find my oven’s model number, which I located inside the door frame. That helped me search for the exact heating element designed for my specific Maytag model. I learned that not every element fits every oven, so matching the part number and specifications was essential.

What I Looked for in a Quality Heating Element

I paid attention to a few important details before buying:

  • Compatibility: I made sure the element matched my Maytag oven model.
  • Material quality: I preferred a durable metal element that could handle repeated high heat.
  • Wattage and voltage: I checked that the power rating matched the original part.
  • Connector style: I verified the terminal ends would fit correctly.
  • Customer reviews: I read feedback to see if other buyers had reliable results.

Signs I Used to Confirm the Element Needed Replacement

Before ordering, I looked for common signs of failure:

  • The oven took too long to preheat.
  • Food cooked unevenly.
  • The element had visible cracks, blisters, or burn marks.
  • I noticed no glow or partial heating during operation.

These signs helped me feel more confident that replacing the element was the right move.

What I Considered Before Buying

I didn’t just choose the cheapest option. I compared:

  • Price: I balanced affordability with durability.
  • Warranty: I preferred a part with some protection in case it failed early.
  • Brand reputation: I trusted sellers with strong ratings and clear product details.
  • Return policy: I made sure I could return the part if it didn’t fit.

My Installation Checklist

Once I had the replacement part, I made sure I was ready to install it safely:

  • I turned off power to the oven at the breaker.
  • I used a screwdriver to remove the old element.
  • I gently pulled the element forward to access the wires.
  • I disconnected and reconnected the terminals carefully.
  • I secured the new element and tested the oven.

My Final Buying Advice

If I were buying a Maytag oven heating element again, I would focus first on exact compatibility and then on quality. In my experience, a correctly matched replacement part saves time, avoids frustration, and restores the oven’s performance much faster. Taking a few minutes to verify the model number and compare options made the whole process much smoother.

Final Thoughts

Replacing a Maytag oven heating element is a straightforward repair that can make a big difference in how well my oven performs. I just need to make sure I choose the correct replacement part, follow safety steps, and install it carefully. In my experience, taking a little time to do it right can save money and help my oven work like new again.

Author Profile

Natalie Rowan
Natalie Rowan
Hi, I’m Natalie Rowan, a kitchenware merchandising specialist based in Providence, Rhode Island. Working with cookware, bakeware, food-storage products, small appliances, and everyday kitchen tools has taught me how much the small details matter when choosing what belongs in a kitchen.

Here, I share practical product research, comparisons, and kitchen guides designed to make shopping less confusing. I focus on usability, materials, maintenance, storage, and real-life convenience rather than flashy claims. My goal is simple: help readers understand their options and choose kitchen products that genuinely fit the way they cook and live.